Double-Take: Lamps Plus vs. Nate Berkus

It's time for another double-take, where we take one item from Target and match it against a similar - yet pricer - piece. Today we're looking at two nautical-inspired hurricane lamps. Both have rope accents and can hold a pillar candle... but one is from Lamps Plus and will set you back almost $90, whereas the other is from the Nate Berkus for Target collection (at Target) and is on sale for $12.50.  Which one is which? The answer appears in the comments section below.